Management-Research Question Hierarchy
Akron Children’s Hospital is a well-establish, highly respected and capable children’s care facility in a highly competitive pediatric health-care market. Akron Children’s Hospital was established in the late 1800’s and has grown to be the “region’s largest pediatric care provider with 253 beds. It offers 30 practice areas of medicine and surgery, specialized for children” (Schindler, 2021). Even with the robust and substantiated reputation of being a leader in innovation, medical excellence and having the largest bed availability, Akron Children’s Hospital was experiencing “overshadowing” by two nationally recognized pediatric care facilities in the region. As a result, Akron Children’s Hospital sought out an outside research company, Marcus Thomas LLC, to devise a new communication strategy. Akron Children’s Hospital’s goal was to distinguish itself from their regional competitors and to communicate “its commitment to children…[and] to the highest-quality and most medically advanced care” (Schindler, 2021).
The management-research question hierarchy for Akron Children’s Hospital is to first identify the management dilemma. The management dilemma is how to attract more customers, or in this case patients, to their hospital care facility verses the regional competitors’ care facilities. The management question is to determine how to differentiate itself from its overshadowing competition. The research questions should focus on how Akron Children’s Hospital can distinguish itself from the competitors in the region by highlighting its strong commitment to children and families in serious- and terminally ill situations with highest-quality and medically innovative pediatric-focused care. Investigative questions include how parents decide on which children’s care facilities they choose for their child’s care and how can Akron Children’s Hospital communicate their robust care and facilities in order to attract more parents to make Akron Children’s Hospital their first choice. Measurement questions that are asked directly to the participants in which researchers observe and record the conversations include: how did the doctors convey to the patient, in this case the ill child, their prognosis, did you feel the doctor and staff were child-focused, did you feel encouraged to stay with your child for the entirety of their stay at the facility, do you agree with the philosophy that being able to stay with your child 24/7 helped with the healing process, did you feel Akron Children’s Hospital truly focused on kids being kids. Additionally, a Likert scale will reveal ordinal nature of the data (Allen & Seaman, 2007) when asking the parents and children to rate on a number scale (1 being strongly disagree and 5 being strongly agree) when assessing the facility, staff and food experiences.
Advantages/Disadvantages of Observation Study
In designing a measurement instrument for the Akron Children’s Hospital study, Marcus Thomas LLC used the communication-based research through covert and overt observation methodology (Slack & Rowley, 2001) to gain information and insight from study
participants. “Researchers listened to, watched, and recorded first-hand physical and emotional reactions and heart-wrenching conversations” (Schindler, 2021). Marcus Thomas LLC also covertly observed doctor interactions with the patients, in this case children, and their parents. The advantage in using observational methodology in the Akron Children’s Hospital case is that the researcher can record what they observe from the primary source. This provides accuracy and reliability of information. In the case of face-to-face interviews with participants, the interviewer can get more in-depth in the subject matter, gleaning more detailed information through follow-up questions as the participant becomes more comfortable and gains rapport with the interviewer. Additionally, observation with recording provides a permanent record of events and responses allowing further analyzation in the future. The disadvantage of using the observation methodology is the cost, including time and financials, of conducting the interviews and observations. Observation study is more time consuming than a self-administered survey; participants may be geographically further away creating cost of time and money to get interviewers to conduct a face-to-fac survey, and physical presence bias, consciously or subconsciously, may have an effect on the participant’s reaction.
What Brand Promise Reveals about Researcher’s Experience and Conclusion
Upon conclusion of the research, Marcus Thomas LLC believed that a compelling brand promise, very specific to Akron Children’s Hospital’s robust attributes could be used to attract more patients to Akron Children’s Hospital, solving the above stated managerial dilemma. The brand promise “Akron Children’s Hospital focuses ALL of the hospital’s resources (energy, creativity, state-of-the-art technology, compassion, technical skill, competence, etc.) toward the simple good of helping every child reach his or her full potential.” (Schindler, 2021) revealed that researchers repeatedly experienced observations of these listed attributes. Observations through overt methods revealed participants reporting that they positively experienced these various attributes of the hospital’s resources. The surveys the researchers used to rate the facility, staff, and food must have revealed data with positive results. Based on the recommended brand promise, researchers concluded that in order to attract more parents to decide which hospital to choose, they must trust the hospital’s reputation, or in this case “brand”. The brand promise facilitates understanding how the organization is to be perceived (Hytti et al, 2015) which influences parents when shaping their decision of which hospital they choose to care for their child.
Designing an Observation Study
If I were designing a similar observational study I would direct the researchers to “obtain valid data on attitudes, likes, dislikes, personal satisfaction, awareness of situation, use of [facilities]” (Dutka & Frankel, 1993). I would direct researchers to record verbal responses, facial reactions, and body language in face-to-face interviews and in covert observation situations. I would advise for researchers to look for locations and situations that they could observe and record hospital staff interaction with patients and parents without presenting possible physical presence bias. Researchers should listen for verbal ques, sometimes subtle in nature. Examples could be sighs, shaky voice, joyful tones, laughter, crying, etc. all verbal indicators of truthful, raw emotion and feelings at the time of an observed interaction.
“Researchers and participants all have the responsibility to behave ethically” (Schindler, 2021). Ethical issues that would surface in hospital studies in general and in this study would be privacy, quality, notice, choice, security, respect, and bias issues. Researchers, in this case Marcus Thomas LLC, have the greatest ethic responsibility because they are serving the needs of Akron Children’s Hospital and the participant. There are strict HIPPA laws to protect patients right to privacy. (Kilbridge, 2003). Legally, the researcher must obtain informed consent before beginning the study. In this study, there are minor children involved, so consent must be gained from their parent or guardian. The researcher also must ensure participant’s right to privacy, confidentiality, and safety. The researcher also has ethical and legal standards to maintain with their sponsor, in this case the hospital. The hospital has a right to quality research, protection of confidentiality, protecting research process information, findings and recommendations. Every member of the research process needs to be mindful and respectful of ethical behavior and legalities. We are reminded to surround ourselves with moral, ethically conscious people in 1 Corinthians 15:33, “Do not be misled: Bad company corrupts good character” (NIV, 2011).
Do you have a similar assignment and would want someone to complete it for you? Click on the ORDER NOW option to get instant services at essayloop.com. We assure you of a well written and plagiarism free papers delivered within your specified deadline.